Skip to content

Diversity and inclusion (D&I) and its challenges have been around for decades and notwithstanding the moral case, brought into sharper focus recently by the global narratives and actions around black lives matter and white privilege, the business case has never been clearer:

  • The McKinsey study showing that a business with greater ethnic diversity are 35% more likely to have financial returns above their industry average
  • Similarly the Boston Consulting Group found companies with more diverse management teams have 19% higher revenues due to innovation

However, in our sector we are still grappling with:

  • Two thirds of firms have zero female representation on their boards
  • Yet many commentators are saying that female leadership will help business thrive in a post Covid-19 world
  • And just 5.4% of construction industry workers are BAME limiting the potential talent represented and the associated benefits
  • Whilst homophobia remains common place in construction, women potentially experience a double whammy: “I can hide that I’m gay but not that I’m a woman”

We know it’s the right thing to do, to build a diverse and inclusive company and all the research points to how it:

  • Fuels innovative thinking, which can release competitive advantage
  • Boosts problem solving through alternative perspectives and ability to overcome obstacles
  • Reflects the diversity of the environments and communities in which we operate and live

Diversity adds richness, insight and perspective within organisations and to leverage this, inclusivity is critical. However, it’s more than having world class policies, rules and targets; embracing D&I is beyond the temptation to create a veneer of good intentions with those statements and stats. It’s about hiring the right leaders and developing your existing leaders to make sure they can cultivate the culture that will maximise inclusion and contribution, within the current and increasing diversity of your workforce.

Perhaps we’ve been trying for too long to ‘solve’ the diversity problem and we need to shift our mind-set, demystify it and learn to celebrate it. Diversity is more to do with nurturing and celebrating the mosaic of human complexity than hoping everyone will come together in a melting pot. It’s not about making us all the same, it’s in the difference, the differing gifts, where the beauty and brilliance is found.

Shifting Mindsets

“Diversity is a fact. Inclusion is a choice, but not just any choice…..the choice to include another human being activates our humanity” (Clark, 2020). The challenge is how to help your leaders embrace diversity with confidence and then create the inclusive conditions, for that sense of belonging, within which the talents of their teams flourish. It’s frequently argued that many organisations have made great strides towards creating diverse teams yet our clients are telling us that they are struggling with inclusion. This is a critical challenge because inclusion is the first step in creating psychological safety in your organisation and it’s this, which drives performance and innovation.

To realise the human and commercial potential of D&I it’s about shifting mind-sets, the beliefs that inform ‘what got us here’ won’t necessarily see us into a fairer sustainable future. You need to be thinking about how to shake your managers and leaders out of their old habits.

Our approach is to help people, in the context of their leadership challenges, unpack the belief system that informs their personal bias or prejudices and enable them to see how that ultimately shapes the choices they make and shapes company culture, for better or worse. Much of this requires them to:

  • Open themselves up one to one in a safe, trusting and confidential coaching context
  • Raise their self-awareness, insight and understanding
  • Boost their human leadership capacities
  • Strengthen their emotional intelligence muscle

If biases are not made conscious (and often this requires more than sheep-dip training) how do you build your businesses talent pipe line from the short list to the way existing talent is developed and promoted, your managers and leaders are at risk of operating with the blinkers on. In this way your business is potentially short changed by not releasing the added value that inclusion, innovation and competitive advantage brings.

We’ve had many brilliant conversations about ‘fit’ with clients for example, whilst crafting search assignments and have been learning together that we really need to pull this idea apart and challenge limiting assumptions. Historically ‘fit’ has potentially risked screening out people who think differently let alone look differently to ‘us’. The whole cognitive difference fact, is a huge part of diversity and many studies are pointing to the amazing results achieved when you hire people for example on the autistic spectrum, or those with dyspraxia, attention deficit, dyslexia and other neuro-divergent ways of being.

Many of our clients are actively embracing the widest spectrum of diverse talent; at the same time they worry about the capabilities of their current management and leadership teams to truly embrace this diversity, let alone ensure inclusion for all.

It is increasingly argued that we need to urgently shift towards true human leadership, where leaders must develop their humanity by growing their mental, emotional and relational capacities. What we think, tends to inform how we feel and shapes what we do or how we act and leaders need to have good self-awareness, insight and understanding, they need good emotional intelligence. If they have this they more readily recognise the importance of empowering their teams to discover, develop and share their gifts, to feel recognised and valued for their difference and talents. There’s a significant part of this that shows up in the imperative for leaders to create environments which provide psychological safety.

Improving staff engagement & retention

If there is a lack of cultural intelligence in your leadership population, you may be exposed to a retention risk. It’s why we coach leaders to boost psychological safety, to become more confident inclusive leaders and develop a stronger human leadership identity and way of being.

It’s unlikely that you will realise the discretionary efforts of employees without your leaders engendering psychological safety and this is a significant differentiator that drives engagement as well as retention and employee value add. Increasingly if your employees report a lack of psychological safety you are unlikely to be an employer of choice and you are unlikely to be embracing diversity and inclusion. Millennial’s are less likely to accept positions with firms that don’t have a reputation for being diverse and inclusive and are also more likely to leave managers/firms who don’t create psychological safety.

As a precondition for inclusion, psychological safety drives performance and innovation and your managers and leaders need to be able to create the environment to bring out the best in all of their talent. The price to pay if they can’t do this, will be inability to attract and retain top talent, which will be especially critical as we all chart our way through the impact of the pandemic with the evisceration of the economy and dismantlement of the psychological contract.

We have a huge challenge in our sector where many of our leaders have come up through the technical professional career route. They are in urgent need of a trusted thinking partner to help them uncover and deploy their human talent to relate, connect and inspire the collaboration that will drive individual and business performance.

The generational power shift and embracing human leadership

Perhaps we are at an interesting turning point in the talent and leadership succession process in our businesses; as the Baby Boomers hang on to their positions of power ahead of retirement and Millennials navigate towards inheriting the business future. Arguably both groups need support in developing more conscious human leadership capability. We surely need much more genuine people centric leadership, where people are our purpose and this is how we will unleash all human potential, which in turn will generate ethical growth and sustainability.

We are already defining what good leadership looks like in a post pandemic world, in the ‘new now’. Boston Consulting Group argue the new reality requires leadership with:

  • The Head: to envision the future and the priorities required to succeed
  • The Heart: to inspire and empower employees
  • The Hands: to ensure innovative and agile-execution capabilities

We are all seeing the check lists emerging and putting strategic and commercial capability aside, our leaders also need to demonstrate:

  • Integrity
  • Self-awareness
  • Gratitude
  • Appreciation
  • Learning agility
  • Empathy
  • Vulnerability
  • Kindness
  • Curiosity
  • Candour
  • Humility
  • Listening to understand
  • Compassion
  • Leading with purpose

A tall order perhaps for some, but we learnt during the crisis phase of the pandemic, that empathy and compassion, which flow from emotional intelligence, have emerged from the businesses that will shine through as exemplars of how to lead people in the future. Not least because especially for now the future remains uncertain.

Given that uncertainty D&I is a business imperative and we need to access the human and commercial gains available when we get it right. Helping leaders shift their mind-set and actively seek to celebrate diversity and behave as an inclusive leader, rather than viewing D&I as a problem to solve, may be part of the answer. Developing the emotional intelligence of your leaders, so that they can build psychological safety as a gateway for inclusion, will help your business become more innovative. This can drive the kind of competitive advantage you need to survive and thrive in the future and to be known as an employer with a strong reputation for Diversity & Inclusion.

At KA Executive we recruit for difference and coach for inclusion and we are constantly instructed by clients to present diverse shortlists, which we are proud to deliver.

When working with clients at the search and selection stage we help to challenge their ideas and thinking by not looking for a narrow definition of ‘fit’, so that we can test their perception of the talent target market. This results in a much richer talent pool to select from and increases  clients potential to recruit for difference.

We also work with you coaching your managers and leaders to enable them to maximise performance and contribution. We help build their capability to nurture and develop their people by embracing Diversity and Inclusion in a way that aligns with navigating the business challenges. In particular we are coaching and mentoring emerging and senior female managers and leaders helping them develop confidence and leverage their human leadership capabilities.

If you’d like to explore how we can help you put diverse shortlists together please contact Karen Armstrong, Director

Tel: +44 (0)7879 630036
E:  karmstrong@KAexecutivesearch.com

If you’d like to explore our coaching for inclusive leadership or you’d welcome some additional input and ideas for your own D&I action plan please contact Liz McGivern, Associate Director Organisational Development and Talent Management. Liz is more than happy to share experience and insights into what clients are doing in this space.

Tel: +44 (0) 7798 797311
E: lmcgivern@KAexecutivesearch.com

Back To Top