Diversity and Inclusion
Beyond gender and BAME targets, to really develop your culture and improve the bottom line
The arguments have been well made, when businesses are truly diverse and inclusive both people and the bottom line benefit. Diversity and inclusion (D&I) goes beyond gender and BAME and includes cognitive or neuro-diversity and its capacity to enable new and different ways of thinking, working and collaborating, driving both engagement and productivity. Deloitte’s recent research found that 46% of HR executives rated, as weak, their organisations provision of formal programmes to help build an inclusive cultural environment.
The drivers for D&I of course include the legal case, the moral case as well as business case to appreciate. The moral or social justice case arguably creates awareness of the importance of how you become an employer of choice, the kind of reputation and employee proposition you offer to attract your share of the talent in the market place. The business case and evidence of positive impact on the bottom line seems to keep growing.
Diversity of thinking as the new frontier, is argued to be the horizon beyond demographic characteristics of gender and race and more than ensuring your workplace is free from discrimination. It’s about building the environment that allows your people to do work that they feel has a purpose, enables them to reach their potential in service of their personal aspirations and is aligned with the needs of the business. Thinking agility and diversity is a wellspring of creativity enhancing innovation by 20% according to Deloitte’s research. It can help teams’ spot risks, reducing these by up to 30% and enable more effective implementation of change by creating buy-in and trust.
Diversity without inclusion is not enough and is set out clearly in Bourke’s (2016) research, which shows organisations with inclusive cultures are:
- 2x more likely to meet or exceed financial targets
- 3x more likely to be high performing
- 6x more likely to be innovative and agile
- 8x more likely to achieve better business outcomes
Deloitte’s research finds that high performing teams are both cognitively and demographically diverse and argue that businesses need to be clear about their definition of inclusion, if they are to hold leaders accountable for it. Their holistic four part model of inclusion (Bourke and Dillon, 2017) comprises: fairness and respect, valued and belonging, safe and open as well as empowering and growing. At its highest point “inclusion is expressed as feeling confident and inspired”.
Arguably it is becoming increasingly accepted that building an inclusive environment, where it is OK and even encouraged, to think differently, is one of the ways to build competitive advantage. A Harvard Business Review article (2017) found that teams with greater diversity of thinking styles are more likely to perform better when faced with new, uncertain and complex challenges.
So if this shines a light on what inclusion might look and feel like, diversity is all about the mix of your current and future workforce needs. At KA Executive we are increasingly partnering with clients to help them review their overall resourcing mix and recruitment strategy, helping them build the talent pools that will add value and drive business performance.
The business case and value of D&I
Research demonstrates a compelling case for D&I as an embedded part of your business strategy, and it requires focussed effort from strong, sustained and inclusive leadership.
Deloitte (2018) argue that D&I are transformative forces and are proven to be linked to business performance and McKinsey’s (2018) report ‘Delivering through Diversity’ found that it boosts employee engagement, job satisfaction and performance. They also found that firms with diverse executive teams are up to 33% more likely to outperform their competitors.
In 2015 McKinsey’s research identified that diversity matters, not least as a driver of innovation and showed that gender diverse companies are 14% more likely to perform better and ethnically diverse companies 35% more likely to perform better that non-diverse firms. Common sense, to the extent that the more varied a team’s collective experiences and backgrounds are, the richer their knowledge base becomes. This further shines a light on the imperative of ensuring your recruitment and development strategies have the right mix of DNA and characteristics to build technological advantage in the digital age.
Building these organisational characteristics goes beyond a nod of the head acceptance of the importance D&I can have for your business and tick box exercises. It’s about finding practical ways to close the gap between aspiration and reality and to move away from relying on training. It has to be insightful learning rooted in the real challenges leaders face and embedding a coaching culture can speed up the pace with which leaders become naturally more curious, caring and inclusive.
The built environment sector and D&I
A recent Willis Towers Watson report (2018, Building Diversity & Inclusion in the Construction Industry) predicts that limited workforce diversity will be a top 20 risk for construction firms through to 2027. Despite increased awareness, progress appears slow; of the 346 companies in McKinsey’s original research (2015) comprising mostly US and UK businesses, gender representation on executive teams has increased only 2% to 14% and ethnic and cultural diversity by just 1% to 13% in 2018. It appears that organisations in our sector are still unclear as to how they can optimally employ D&I to drive business growth and value creation.
Yet diverse organisations are better at attracting the talent they need especially when it comes to attracting Millennials, who will make up fifty percent of the global workforce by 2020. 47% of Millennials consider D&I as an important factor when considering a new job offer.
According to Diversity UK, ethnic minorities make up 12% of the working age population and the recent Glenigan (2018) construction industry report showed, that the average workforce within construction companies was just 3% black or minority ethnic employees. The proportion of women has actually dropped from 19% to 13% and so the industry is not representative of the communities in which it operates. An issue which the International Federation of Consulting Engineers has now set up a diversity and inclusion taskforce to tackle. Firms are missing out on a pool of potential talent, at a time when skill shortages remain high and recruiting new entrants to the industry is one of our critical challenges.
A shift in culture is needed to ensure the sector aligns its talent resourcing and development strategies with the new realities. This not only means your vision, mission, values and employee value proposition, need to be aligned, it also requires investing in the development of your managers and leaders to become agile and inclusive in their approach to creating an environment to attract, retain and develop the best talent in their own teams.
Senior allies are instrumental in driving cultural change as Mott McDonald have found with 81% of their staff believing that equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) are taken seriously in the business and 72% saying that EDI policies are implemented effectively. They have also seen EDI principles adopted by clients, contractors and suppliers and increasingly are embedded in clients’ tenders. So arguably being a diverse and inclusive supplier is progressively likely to be a factor in keeping your business on the invitation to tender lists. It seems to take concerted, cohesive and collaborative action and appears that inclusion doesn’t just happen.
Building and growing diverse and inclusive teams
Make sure you build diversity and inclusion into your recruitment strategy, it may not just be about looking for people who ‘fit’ but actively including those who don’t fit, this might be a way to enrich your existing DNA. Check your role profiles, they typically shape the way your recruitment pitches are written, and ask yourself is the criteria and language helping or hindering your ability to attract a diverse pool of candidates. Are there enough people in your teams who can see things differently and challenge as well as support current approaches to problem solving and add to the potency of your learning culture? Are your executive search partners aligned to your D&I strategy and can represent you culturally in the competitive market place and help you onboard new and diverse talent to boost retention.
Leaders must be encouraged to have an open mind-set and value diversity and they need to feel confident in facilitating the value of difference. It’s essential they understand the individuals in their team and have a coherent context within which to be managing and leading. With the right support, you can hold leaders accountable and enable them to create inclusive and collaborative ways of working, where performance and contribution are optimised. Coaching leaders in developing a more agile and inclusive style of management, builds their confidence and know how, enabling rapid applied actions in a way that they embody and become role models for diversity and inclusion. Our clients continue to struggle to get their technical professional managers to work in new ways. We are working with clients to build leadership capability through coaching, and experienced based talent development programmes contributing towards building a coaching culture focused on achieving high performance.
Continuing to embrace flexible working practiceswill make sure you are attracting diverse valuable talent and embracing flexibility. As the Bain & Co research (2016) points out the increase in dual incomes households, the aging population and the new expectations of Millennials is driving the need for organisations to think creatively about the flexible ways work and roles can be organised, for senior positions as well.
Increasingly it looks as if competitive advantage may go to companies whose workforces look more like the communities where they work. D&I inspires businesses with new ideas, fresh and alternative perspectives and a willingness to consider alternative approaches to getting things done. A more diverse workforce means, better problem solving and decision making enabling built environment companies to outperform competitors.
How KA can help:
KA Executive can help you review the diversity mix in your existing talent pools and develop the resourcing strategies to attract and onboard a diverse mix of professionals to help you secure your share of talent. We also work with clients to help them develop and retain their talent through high quality, value for money executive and leadership coaching and cost effective bespoke L&D approaches, aimed at building a high performing team and business culture.
We’ve been working with clients helping them ensure their talent management strategies and processes are built to embrace diversity and inclusion. Our coaches work with global leaders and appreciate the cross-cultural dimensions of leveraging the talents of diverse teams.
At KA, coaching is about partnering with clients to inspire them to maximise their personal and professional potential. We empower clients to become experts in managing their own lives and lived experiences and to make sense of these. Instilling this personal accountability is critical in promoting a diverse workforce, where everyone from your most junior employees to executive leadership, can ‘walk the talk’.
Coaching goes beyond training for D&I and adds an important dimension to building a coaching culture. Particularly key with high potential talent, who often include in reasons for leaving, a feeling that their voice was not being heard. We work to encourage people to think for themselves and to encourage this in their own teams, so that they can think beyond historic limiting assumptions towards great creativity, personal power and effectiveness. All essential ingredients in building a high performing team.
We can help you craft better diversity and inclusive approaches into your talent management strategy to boost your competitive edge, we can also help you reset and build your culture, and not just tick the boxes.
